Do cynics get dementia quicker? Call me cynical, however… – Telegraph Blogs

‘Cynicism is an disagreeable approach of talking the reality,” in accordance with Lillian Hellman, whose personal relationship with fact, if we’re to consider her enemy, Mary McCarthy, was decidedly distant. Nevertheless Hellman’s definition is traditionally correct. The Ancient Greek faculty of cynic philosophers prided themselves on their lack of illusions concerning the world and human nature. So they took pleasure in stating unpleasant truths.

In the widespread sense of the phrase, we usually tend to agree with Oscar Wilde, who stated a cynic “knew the worth of every thing and the worth of nothing”. This is a lovely judgment as a result of you’ll be able to apply it to politicians and NHS directors, although each teams would virtually definitely be offended in case you did so.

Be that as it might, there’s something agreeably bitter concerning the cynic, the person who refuses to be impressed by protestations of advantage, takes a dim view of human nature, and sometimes, like Jonathan Swift, bitingly exposes the follies and delusions of mankind.

Now, nevertheless, the biter is in peril of being bitten – if, that’s, we’re to consider a analysis research from the University of Eastern Finland: it concludes that the cynic is 3 times extra more likely to develop dementia in previous age than are these sunny people who take a extra rosy view of humanity.

The research itself isn’t more likely to be discovered convincing by scientists and statisticians, as a result of the pattern surveyed was very small, and truly only a few in both class – the bitter-confronted and the smiling – developed the distressing situation. And but it’s not, once you consider it, a completely shocking conclusion. If you’re low-spirited and undergo life considering badly of others, you may nicely sink into such deep melancholy that you simply lose your marbles.

Swift himself is a working example. One of probably the most, savage – and satisfying – of satirists, he succumbed to dementia, and spent his final years as a gibbering wreck, whose servants are stated to have put him on present, displaying him to the curious on cost of a small charge. You might say the servants have been themselves displaying a level of cynicism in addition to greed. At any fee, they could be held to have justified his personal low opinion of mankind.

Neither Reagan’s sunny optimism nor Thatcher’s ethical fervour spared them from dementia’s scythe (Pic: AP)

We know too little of what Shakespeare’s personal opinions have been, even when his description of “lust in motion” as “the expense of spirit in a waste of disgrace” could seem a somewhat cynical view of sexual ardour. Usually once we cite him we’re quoting what he thought proper to place within the mouths of the characters he had created. But the opinions he gave to “melancholy” Jacques within the “Seven Ages of Man” speech in As You Like It is perhaps fixed on by the Finnish researchers.

Jacques is, certainly, a little bit of a cynic who speaks of “the foul physique of th’contaminated world”, and for him the seventh age of Man is evidently certainly one of dementia: “Last scene of all,/ That ends this unusual eventual historical past,/ Is second childishness and mere oblivion,/ Sans tooth, sans eyes, sans style, sans every thing.” That’s a good description of dementia, lengthy earlier than Dr Alois Alzheimer studied on the University of Tuebingen.

Since the trigger or causes of dementia haven’t but been established, it’s not shocking that researchers might attempt to set up whether or not individuals of a sure temperament usually tend to contract it than others. But even if so, and the Finnish research is on to one thing, it’s onerous to see what may be carried out about it. Whether one is an optimist or pessimist, a believer within the important goodness of our fellow-males or a cynic, is just partially a matter of temperament; it might even be the results of expertise.

Small youngsters are not often cynics and cynicism in adolescents is usually a pose. Later in grownup life it’s fairly standard for individuals to be coldly cynical about some issues, warmly hopeful about others. We are not often all of a bit. In a sure temper we might agree with the French moralist who stated that there’s all the time one thing pleasing within the misfortunes of our associates, and smile fortunately at Gore Vidal’s statement that “it isn’t sufficient to succeed; others should fail” – two splendidly cynical remarks. Yet in a sunnier temper, one might discover such cynicism revolting.

We all dread dementia, however there isn’t any proof that our angle to life will decide whether or not we succumb to it or escape it. Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher have been each referred to as many issues by their enemies, however no one would have charged both with cynicism; however neither the one’s sunny optimism nor the opposite’s ethical fervour was sufficient to allow them to retain all their psychological schools. Dementia takes many prisoners, however does so indiscriminately.

Indeed, regardless of the Finns say, there would appear to be just one means to make certain of not being caught within the lure of dementia, and that’s to die earlier than it grips you.

I suppose some would say that may be a cynical thought. It definitely matches Hellman’s definition of cynicism, being an disagreeable means of talking the reality.

Get the latest comment and analysis from the Telegraph

Read more from our news and politics bloggers

!perform(d,s,id)var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0],p=/^http:/.check(d.location)?’http’:’https’;if(!d.getElementById(id))js=d.createElement(s);;js.src=p+’://’;fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);(doc H:06 pm – Source:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.